diff --git a/fastanime/cli/service/registry/service.py b/fastanime/cli/service/registry/service.py
index 1cbeba6..f58dc99 100644
--- a/fastanime/cli/service/registry/service.py
+++ b/fastanime/cli/service/registry/service.py
@@ -191,6 +191,8 @@ class MediaRegistryService:
         else:
             if not index_entry.status:
                 index_entry.status = UserMediaListStatus.WATCHING
+            elif index_entry.status == UserMediaListStatus.COMPLETED:
+                index_entry.status = UserMediaListStatus.REPEATING
 
         if last_watch_position:
             index_entry.last_watch_position = last_watch_position
diff --git a/fastanime/cli/service/watch_history/service.py b/fastanime/cli/service/watch_history/service.py
index af9dc3b..6a04aad 100644
--- a/fastanime/cli/service/watch_history/service.py
+++ b/fastanime/cli/service/watch_history/service.py
@@ -28,6 +28,11 @@ class WatchHistoryService:
         )
         status = None
 
+        if (
+            media_item.user_status
+            and media_item.user_status.status == UserMediaListStatus.COMPLETED
+        ):
+            status = UserMediaListStatus.REPEATING
         self.media_registry.update_media_index_entry(
             media_id=media_item.id,
             watched=True,